Goshen Township Breeder Sentenced After Scamming Puppy Buyers
Justice is expected to be served for dozens of individuals—both human and canine—caught in a devastating puppy scam that spanned across Ohio and beyond.
On Thursday, April 24, April Waidman of Goshen Township will be sentenced in Mahoning County Court after pleading guilty to over 80 charges, including 45 felony theft counts. Waidman admitted to taking payments for puppies that customers never received, defrauding families across the country of more than $106,000.
The case, investigated and exposed by a 21 News Watchdog report, revealed a wide pattern of deceit. While some individuals successfully received dogs, many were left heartbroken and out hundreds—or even thousands—of dollars after placing deposits for puppies that were never delivered.
Prosecutors are recommending:
6 months in jail
5 years of probation
A ban on dog breeding while on probation
Victims from across the Mahoning Valley and as far as California are expected to attend the sentencing hearing, hoping for accountability and closure.
Why This Matters
This case is about more than financial loss. It’s about protecting animals from exploitation and ensuring ethical breeding practices. Puppy scams like this don’t just harm families—they fuel unregulated breeding operations, jeopardize animal welfare, and undermine legitimate rescue and adoption efforts.
Ohio Animal Advocates supports stronger enforcement and oversight to ensure breeders are held accountable for both animal care and consumer trust.
What You Can Do
Be a smart adopter: Always research breeders thoroughly. Look for transparency, verifiable references, and in-person visits. When in doubt, adopt from a reputable shelter or rescue.
Report suspected scams or cruelty: If something feels off, trust your instincts and report it to local authorities or humane law enforcement. You can find who to call in your county to report animal cruelty using OAA statewide resource list.
Support legislation that increases penalties for cruelty and breeder oversight: OAA continues to advocate for stronger laws to protect both pets and the public. Ask you state senator to support and co-sponsor S.B. 64 to enhance penalties for felony animal cruelty.
This case is a reminder that justice for animals often begins with accountability for people. We’ll continue to follow the outcome of this sentencing and advocate for those without a voice.
Source 21WFMJ
